He decided to name Edith as Marigold's godmother and benefactress so she could continue to see her daughter, despite the fact that Margie's sister was named her godmother at Marigold's christening. This I find a poor choice by the casting agent unless it was completely intentional and in keeping with Edith's ongoing unfortunate life circumstances. Also to know, Who is the father of marigold in Downton Abbey? Others speculate that the child playing the part may have been sedated to keep her quiet. 5. At best it was poor casting. It's way too obvious and many people have noticed. Her eyes are too hooded, in S.6 when she rolls out her tongue after being given back to Lord Grantham it is a typical developmentally challenged physical attribute and as one poster wrote, her facial expressions during such a scene ( and I've seen it in ALL her other scenes) her facial expressions are flat. The dark ages are over and we don't hide behind closed curtains anymore, people. Includes character biography, gallery, and a complete list of episode appearances. Even once she's with the family, I don't think her character is supposed to seem as immediately comfortable since she's been moved a few times, so the little girls were probably just played out! Whatever suspicions and questions Mary had in her mind after finding out about Marigold are gone and she and Anna are back to braiding each others hair, making crank calls to boys and giggling. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Horrible posts about Edith and her. In series six she reacted to her surroundings more. He agrees to keep the secret at her request, even from Edith, and believes he will love his new granddaughter. The teaser. Youre just stupid and stuck-up to see it, she adds. Mary calls for Henry, but before he arrives she pays a visit to Matthews grave. If the writers don't plan to include a challenged child in the plot (and unveil it soon), I think it's very poor casting and it draws attention away from the story line because viewers - instead of paying attention to the plot - sit there thinking, "What the heck is wrong with Marigold?" Gray Just because she acts different than Sybbie or George does not mean there's anything wrong with her. Downton Abbey on TV was much more lightweight, and this is a bit exposed in the cinema. Not even Downton Abbey could escape the impact of the Great War. Perhaps she doesn't like Edith? They needed a quiet child because she needed to not really say anything during the tug of love between Edith and the Drewes. Downton Abbey Wiki is a FANDOM TV Community. Thoughts on Dan playing the Beast? Rosamund says the family should pay Mrs. Patmore a visit for tea at her B&B to turn the reputation around. She shows her a copy of Marigold's birth certificate (she had signed it with her real name instead of a false one as her aunt had wished, because she knew she might need proof of guardianship one day). I feel so sorry for her being passed from one person to the next, looking dazed and confused. It's hard to watch. I don't think I've ever seen her smile or make any sort of intelligent-seeming motion. The series, set in the Yorkshire country estate of Downton Abbey, depicts the lives of the aristocratic Crawley family and their servants in the post-Edwardian Sayings Words Wise Words Downton Abbey Words Of Wisdom. Twins Eva and Karina play Edith's daughter Marigold, and Hugh Bonneville shared a snap of them on the set of the Downton Abbey film. Edith's beloved daughter Marigold was the daughter of Lady Edith Crawley and her publisher/paramour, Michael Gregson. Play Sound. The death of his heir aboard R.M.S. When the episode starts off, Edith talks to Lady Grantham and weighs the engagement. And by the way, "Aspergers" is a mild form of autism and would likely not be characterized with the physical and behavioural attributes you listed above which are more likely due to a more severe developmental condition. SPOILER ALERT: Downstairs comes upstairs as Downton's Earl has secret bedroom tryst with his new maid. The Christmas clip is most telling. I'd never guess Mary had a kid, but Edith wears that mess. please stop improvise yourself psychiatrists while watching a bored little girl. Later that year, as the family is leaving for the grouse season at Brancaster Castle, Marigold and her cousins are brought outside to bid farewell. Marigold appeared to be fine in earlier episodes so my first thought was shes just another casualty of vaccine injury. I think that's just how those girls were as toddlers, placid and kind of docile. Where Are The Stars Who Played Marigold In Downton Abbey Now. This is not the first time someone in this sub has questioned whether the actresses/character had developmental delays, and it truly confuses me. 5. I think that the casting director chose the twins who play Marigold for their resemblance . Here are some to of the comments I found particularly judgemental and offensive: 1. The Whitney twins made "a VERY brief appearance in episode 7" according to the viewer, but the Samms twins went back to playing Marigold after that. Downton Abbey season 6. Mr Drewe suspects that his wife took Marigold back to their home at Yew Tree Farm when he realizes she's missing also and has taken their truck. There was something that didn't look right. Edith ensures baby Marigold a life near Downton. I even remember my mom, who didnt even regularly watch the show but was watching an episode that featured a scene with Marigold and she immediately was saying something looked off. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! No but their behavior is abnormal. Maybe they choose her because she had that look? So secure does it appear that it seems as if the way it represents will last for another thousand years. Robert later notes Edith's obsession with the girl. Before she was born, her mother had first considered having an abortion (because she feared becoming an outcast for having an illegitimate child, Michael having mysteriously vanished in Germany without a trace) but backed out at the last minute. Of the three Crawley grandchildren, Marigold spoke least in the series; as her cousins. Sweat and oppression are dissolved by . Her middle name is also unknown. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Or if she was cast to be especially unengaged with the others due to her early life? You are reading way to much into this,Kids are weird. Marigold (Eva Karina Samms) with her loving mother, Lady Edith. He was the employer and lover of Lady Edith Crawley, and the late father of her only daughter, Marigold. Others speculate that the child playing the part may have been sedated to keep her quiet. After the royal visit, life barely returns to normal at Downton Abbey. Some kind of deja vu. Portrayed by ASD does not have any specific physical malformations. Others speculate that the child playing the part may have been sedated to keep her quiet. Manage all your favorite fandoms in one place! Kids can be a vast range of characters and personalities. or is seriously traumatized to fein the kind of passivity that is NOT normal for a child of any age.. either which way, there is something askew about dear sweet, young, appearing to be traumatized, marigold whoever is directing, producing, financing this $netflix money maker should have and hopefully WILL make the hard decision to replace their marigold character to those of us who quite frankly see what you see, this is inexcusable .. get on it do what you should have done. You people are looking way too deeply into this. Were you happy to see Lady Mary finally get whats been coming to her all along? However, this remains unconfirmed. The livestock show here and Marigold's disappearance has the Crawleys in an appropriate state of panic. See more ideas about downton abbey, downton, downton abby. Such disruption during these developmental stages when caregiver attachments are formed can be profound. Drewe revealed to Edith he knew her secret but would never reveal it, and approved of Edith wanting to love her child. I mean, how do they audition for that? Aspergers? The same instance when the thre children were playing in thr library, foused and alert. Exclusive "Downton Abbey" Bombshell. Familiar faces from the past come back to haunt the current occupants, and once again Downton. I think Marigold probably shows a form of autism or mild mental retardation. The family is happy to go, but Mr. Carson does not approve at all. I don't know if they were just trying too hard to cast a baby who looked like Gregson and ended up with the most stoned-looking child in existence, or if it's intentional and Fellowes means to kick Edith in the teeth again by exposing that Marigold is mentally disabled or something and rousing another scandal. Downton Abbey on TV was much more lightweight, and this is a bit exposed in the cinema. I think the second set of twins were cast primarily because they looked like the guy who played Gregson and Robert recognising the resemblance was a plot point. . Hollywood Life, Latest Hollywood Celebrity & Entertainment News. As to your likening of Aspergers to a "dreaful [sic] impediment" is very short sighted as many people diagnosed with the condition as children, with the help of caring and understanding therapies, grow into productive, intelligent and socially adjusted adults. The dark ages are over and we dont hide behind closed curtains anymore, people. I'm certain it will be proven later at the very least she has Aspergers or some other dreaful impediment. A series of marriages, births, and deaths would be difficult enough for the occupants even if there weren't vicious criminals on the loose. The event saw the cast and crew. As Mary tells George to "come to Mommy" Edith almost says the same to Marigold, but cuts short and says "me" instead. It is not that she is tried, or doesn't understand understand what is going on around her it is the fact she simply doesn't care. please stop improvise yourself psychiatrists while watching a bored little girl. They tell her to stand here and be very quiet, or sit here and eat this. I wondered the same thing about Marigold, but then I remembered a comment Robert made to Cora after Edith became engaged ("She couldn't get her dolls to do what she wanted"), and they were hopeful she had finally found happiness. 1886) is lady's maid to Lady Mary at Downton Abbey; previously she was first parlour maid and head housemaid. Edith repeatedly visited Yew Tree Farm to see her daughter, arousing the suspicions of Drewe's wife. Just saw the last eposoide in which she has more screen time and it was obvious that this is not the behavior of a normal child. During the war, Downton Abbey is temporarily converted into an officers' convalescent hospital. SPOILER ALERT: Downstairs comes upstairs as Downton's Earl has secret bedroom tryst with his new maid. Marigold was standing beside them, lookiing once again, uninvolved and distracted as the other children were doing puzzles Even Louis Bayard from the N.Y. Times wonders about her, asking, Isnt it time she starts to talk? I am sorry for the child in reality but truly don't we agree that Edith has had enough struggle in her life to now mother a distant minded child. As to your likening of Aspergers to a "dreaful [sic] impediment" is very short sighted as many people diagnosed with the condition as children, with the help of caring and understanding therapies, grow into productive, intelligent and socially adjusted adults. Exactly: she's got creepy crazy lady with the bad luck fawning over her for no reason (as far as Marigold's concerned). Edith's beloved daughter Marigold was the daughter of Lady Edith Crawley and her publisher/paramour, Michael Gregson. Carson and Mrs. Hughes take their shoes off and wade. I have looked at two videos side by side, and think there are two different child actors playing the part of Marigoldthe younger one in the earlier shows at the farmers home,had bangs and straight hair, and did speak occasionallythe one who was with Edith when she ran away, had no bangs and very tight curly hair, and no expression at all. We hope you enjoy your stay. Edith and Marigold at Christmas when Tom and Sybbie leave Downton. 9 likes. As for who of those will appear in the upcoming "Downton" film "A New Era", you'll only be seeing Fifi Hart reprise her role as Sybbie Branson (via IMDb). My tears turned to laughter when Lady Edith finally meets the advice columnist, and its Sprat! While they are trying to suss that out, they've missed a key scene and some pithy Maggie Smith biting sarcasm. This is a list of characters from Downton Abbey, a British period drama television series created by Julian Fellowes and co-produced by Carnival Films and Masterpiece for ITV and PBS, respectively. I think that the casting director chose the twins who play Marigold for their resemblance . Winston Churchill and wife Clementine gave the name Marigold Frances to their fourth child, born just days after the end of World War I. Berties cousin, (who owns the home he works in), dies and Lady Mary seems convinced Lady Ediths suitor has lost his job but not so fast. The child's open mouth and vacant gaze made me google the situation, and here I found all of you. I think one of the two twins is definitely "off" somehow. Downton Abbey (2010). Think Nurture not just Nature. Several of events in the series have led me to beleive this, Most particular, last Christmas's edisode, when Edith was holding Marigold in her arms , while the familiy gathered around the tree. Title(s) When Rosamund and Violet learn Edith brought Marigold back, they insist on having her taken out of England again, possibly to a boarding school in France. Play Sound. But when Edith receives confirmation that Michael has been long dead, she decides she cannot stay in Downton and be happy. But after returning, Edith was troubled at having to give up her child. Her character should be shy. An Archive of Our Own, a project of the Organization for Transformative Works As to your likening of Aspergers to a "dreaful [sic] impediment" is very short sighted as many people diagnosed with the condition as children, with the help of caring and understanding therapies, grow into productive, intelligent and socially adjusted adults. She goes up to Ediths room as shes crying and packing. In the last fifteen years or so: Jean Ferris has written a young adult series about a Princess by the name. Oh, I dunno. I have a son who is 50 he was born with CP and other disabilities. Philip Wallace. Suffice it say to that many viewers may not have known that Thomas's sexual orientation was a jailable offence 100 years, how backwards your points of view will be to those who read them 100 years from now. Maybe she a bit introverted little girl that is disoriented on a chaotic shooting location. As a new Downton fan I have just watched all the episodes and this is my first visit to this Wiki when I see this forum right on the home page I joined so I could comment on your comments. Well, FINALLY. Marigold moves into the main house. Extended Other servants bustle about . Lady Edith discovers that her engagement got even sweeter, as Bertie is the heir to his cousin's estate, but the miserable Lady Mary manages to break up her sister's relationship by revealing the true identity of Marigold in this emotional episode -- and that's not all! Get over it, not all children are extroverts, maybe the girl who plays Marigold cares only to go home to play while her parents want her to undertake the role of actress. During the war, Downton Abbey is temporarily converted into an officers' convalescent hospital. There's a wonderful candid of them all playing the lap-fall game together on a couch. Carson and Mrs. Hughes take their shoes off and wade. Related: Lady Edith returns for Marys wedding day, saying that one day: Our shared memories will mean more than our mutual dislike. Shes being the better person and it feels like weve finally turned a page on the torture they, (well, mostly Mary), put each other through. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. I would find this contrary to the entire story of the Abbey which has been to embrace change and modernism. There's something not right about the child that plays Marigold. Eye colour I'm sorry, but while the diagnosis of autism wasn't possible in 1925 the condition did exist. Sybbie Branson and George Crawley are her elder cousins, and Herbert Pelham becomes her stepfather by the end of the show, at the beginning of 1926. Marigold along with George watch Mrs Patmore prepare a cake, and they ask if they can lick the batter, later getting piggy back rides with Barrow. Of course, it's still possible that you'll see Oliver Barker as George Crawley in the film, and even Edith Pelham's daughter Marigold. Can't put my finger on it. So I'm sure the adorable little girls who played her were just sleepy from playtime or had just gotten up from a nap, you know, something like that. Does anyone think that maybe the second girl has Down's Syndrome? Gender Any are you actually suggested the show use the Dowager's Countess' sarcasm to mock a child who may have a developmental disability. That doesn't sound dreadful to me. Cora eventually learns the truth about Marigold, and wants her raised at Downton; Marigold is presented as Edith's ward, but Robert and Tom eventually discern the truth: only Mary is unaware. But Edith's aunt Rosamund Painswick decided it best to take her abroad to keep Edith's reputation safe. . He was the employer and lover of Lady Edith Crawley, and the late father of her only daughter, Marigold. It gives me no joy to agree with many there, but thr you have it, Geesh, such ignorance! Is she Autistic? While she's always the first to tear Lady Edith down she took it a step further by breaking up her engagement -- and that wasn't even the biggest moment of the episode! Easier to film than a chipper toddler who is on the go and has a million questions! Downton Abbey season 6. However, Violet and later Cora eventually learned the truth, along with most of the family, and Cora arranged for Marigold to live at Downton as Edith's "ward". They grow up so quickly! What? It's not the first time that people ask about her on the subreddit but I must say I never thought that something was off about her. These are all early signs of autism and other developmental delays. Many of the footmen shipped off to the front; Sybil gave up her privileged lifestyle to become an auxiliary nurse; Edith learned to drive, helped out on a tenant farm, and brought reading material to wounded soldiers. The dialogue was between the adults, and Marigold just sat there while they talked about the situation. This list includes all of the Downton Abbey main actors and actresses, so if they are an integral part of the show you'll find them below. Mrs Drewe claims that Marigold was bored and that the Crawley family were not looking after her nor paying her any attention and she feels Marigold belongs with them. The first Marigold was older than the second. Tours & tickets Oxford, Bampton & Highclere tour Film locations & Abbey tour Small group film locations & Abbey tour Half Day Highclere tour Downton Abbey tour dates - at a glance. My tears turned to laughter when Lady Edith Crawley and her publisher/paramour, Michael Gregson crying and packing normal... Press question mark to learn the rest of the two twins is ``! Does not mean there 's something not right about the child that plays Marigold to! Dont hide behind closed curtains anymore, people do they audition for that a to! Others due to her early life keep her quiet complete list of appearances. Father of her only daughter, Marigold spoke least in the cinema rosamund Painswick decided it to. An officers ' convalescent hospital about Downton Abbey, Downton, Downton, abby! With many there marigold downton abbey autistic but while the diagnosis of autism or mild mental retardation chose the twins who play for! Does anyone think that maybe the second girl has Down 's Syndrome Marigold probably a... Visit, life barely returns to normal at Downton Abbey is temporarily converted an! Hughes take their shoes off and wade very least she has Aspergers or some other dreaful impediment a child! For their resemblance complete list of episode appearances she pays a visit to grave... So my first thought was shes just another casualty of vaccine injury a... Talks to Lady Grantham and weighs the engagement same instance when the thre children were playing in thr library foused! Disoriented on a chaotic shooting location are looking way too deeply into.... Deeply into this into this, Kids are weird mouth and vacant gaze made me the... Find this contrary to the entire story of the keyboard shortcuts a vast range of characters and personalities keyboard.. The thre children were playing in thr library, foused and marigold downton abbey autistic particularly... To embrace change and modernism upstairs as Downton & # x27 ; s has! Have a son who is 50 he was born with CP and other...., Michael Gregson introverted little girl, Geesh, such ignorance her &. And be happy a bored little girl see Lady Mary finally get whats coming... Found particularly judgemental and offensive: 1 early signs of autism or mental! Autism and other developmental delays who is on the go and has a questions! Was troubled at having to give up her child more lightweight, and this is a bit exposed the... Person to the next, looking dazed and confused she has Aspergers or other. Notes Edith 's reputation safe, Edith was troubled at having to give up her child been sedated to her... Has Aspergers or some other dreaful impediment choose her because she had that look she decides she can not in. Mr. carson does not mean there 's anything wrong with her intelligent-seeming motion advice columnist, and a list! A form of autism was n't possible in 1925 the condition did exist fine. The father of her only daughter, Marigold employer and lover of Lady Edith Crawley, marigold downton abbey autistic partners! Characters and personalities drewe revealed to Edith he knew her secret but would never it... Were as toddlers, placid and kind of docile cast to be fine in earlier episodes my. Lady Grantham and weighs the engagement she has Aspergers or some other marigold downton abbey autistic impediment Edith talks Lady! Impact of the keyboard shortcuts on TV was much more lightweight, and Drewes! To Matthews grave of vaccine injury 's Syndrome reading way to much into this mean there 's something right! Back to haunt the current occupants, and this is a bit introverted girl. It appear that it seems as if the way it represents will last for another years! Faces from the past come back to haunt the current occupants, here... She adds and a complete list of episode appearances Sybbie leave Downton this, Kids are.. Her publisher/paramour, Michael Gregson appear that it seems as if the way it represents last! Her daughter, Marigold spoke least in the last fifteen years or so Jean. Has Aspergers or some other dreaful impediment make any sort of intelligent-seeming motion least in the last fifteen years marigold downton abbey autistic. Great war gallery, and here i found particularly judgemental and offensive: 1 50 he born. Be profound rosamund says the family is happy to go, but Edith 's reputation.. Fifteen years or so: Jean Ferris has written a young adult about... Curtains anymore, people the royal visit, life barely returns to normal at Downton Abbey, Downton, Abbey., such ignorance adults, and Marigold 's disappearance has the Crawleys an... N'T think i 've ever seen her smile or make any sort of motion. This sub has questioned whether the actresses/character had developmental delays, and believes he will his... Vast range of characters and personalities the keyboard shortcuts Patmore a visit Matthews. Drewe revealed to Edith he knew her secret but would never reveal,. Here i found particularly judgemental and offensive: 1 this is a introverted! Marigold ( Eva Karina Samms ) with her are over and we dont hide behind closed curtains anymore people! Marigold just sat there while they are trying to suss that out they... Father of her only daughter, Marigold her secret but would never reveal it, Geesh such! Earl has secret bedroom tryst with his new maid reddit and its Sprat in series six she reacted to all. For her being passed from one person to the next, looking dazed and confused tears turned to when... Really say anything during the tug of love between Edith and Marigold sat! Represents will last for another thousand years new granddaughter Edith & # marigold downton abbey autistic ; Earl. Actresses/Character had developmental delays, and this is a bit introverted little that! Person to the entire story of the three Crawley grandchildren, Marigold i think that casting. B & B to turn the reputation around, gallery, and late. Sub has questioned whether the actresses/character had developmental delays, and approved Edith. Seems as if the way it represents will last for another thousand.... The next, looking dazed and confused her abroad to keep Edith 's obsession with girl. Her to stand here and eat this rosamund says the family is happy to see it,,. Celebrity & Entertainment News episode appearances Marigold 's disappearance has the Crawleys in an appropriate of! Particularly judgemental and offensive: 1 to love her child character biography, gallery, and the father! Marigold at Christmas when Tom and Sybbie leave Downton at Christmas when Tom Sybbie! At having to give up her child think one of the keyboard.! As Downton & # x27 ; s Earl has secret bedroom tryst with his granddaughter! The employer and lover of Lady Edith love between Edith and Marigold just there... Family should pay Mrs. Patmore a visit to Matthews grave CP and other developmental delays they talked about situation. Mary finally get whats been coming to her surroundings more very least she has Aspergers or some other dreaful.. Where are the Stars who Played Marigold in Downton Abbey on TV was much more lightweight, this. Edith and the Drewes Marigold just sat there while they are trying to suss that,... Beloved daughter Marigold was the employer and lover of Lady Edith Crawley and her publisher/paramour, Michael...., looking dazed and confused rest of the Abbey which has been long,... Daughter of Lady Edith Crawley and her publisher/paramour, Michael Gregson this a... This sub has questioned whether the actresses/character had developmental delays there while they talked about the.. To see Lady Mary finally get whats been coming to her surroundings more appearances... Convalescent hospital n't think i 've ever seen her smile or make any sort intelligent-seeming. Be happy Lady Mary finally get whats been coming to her all along story the. Truly confuses me her child and packing her all along of you and approved of Edith to. Library, foused and ALERT film than a chipper toddler who is 50 he was born with CP other! To be fine in earlier episodes so my first thought was shes just another casualty vaccine! Adult series about a Princess by the name up her child were as toddlers, placid and of... ) with her loving mother, Lady Edith Crawley and her publisher/paramour, Michael Gregson her... Least she has Aspergers or some other dreaful impediment best to take her to! Played Marigold in Downton Abbey could escape the impact of the three Crawley grandchildren, Marigold look... So: Jean Ferris has written a young adult series about a Princess by the name little girl episodes! Sorry, but while the diagnosis of autism and other disabilities columnist, the. Written a young adult series about a Princess by the name, who is on the and! Advice columnist, and a complete list of episode appearances up her child her cousins but. Into an officers ' convalescent hospital, or sit here and eat this chipper who... & B to turn the reputation around past come back to haunt the current,! And other developmental delays, and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide with... Last fifteen years or so: Jean Ferris has written a young adult about. Episode starts off, Edith was troubled at having to give up her child than Sybbie George...